An Auckland Law School academic is arguing that copyright law should better recognise and protect what he says are the distinct features of human creativity, as generative AI systems increasingly produce music, writing and images.
The argument is set out in a forthcoming article in the journal Legalities by Dr Joshua Yuvaraj, a copyright scholar and co-director of the University of Auckland’s New Zealand Centre for Intellectual Property.
Yuvaraj’s paper asks why copyright offices and courts “worldwide seem adamant that copyright protection should only extend to works of human creativity,” and what that implies about the value society places on human creative work.
He identifies three defining features of human creativity—emotions, morality and community—drawing on research from psychology, neuroscience and other disciplines. “Emotions connect people to each other on a deeper level; moral thinking matters to ensure what we create is good for the world; and community matters ever more in a fragmented, lonely age,” he says.
The paper frames the debate as governments consider issues including ownership of AI-generated works, whether AI companies can use copyrighted material for training, and how artists should be compensated when their work is used in or displaced by automated systems.
Yuvaraj argues that copyright protection should apply only when there is “genuine creative input” from a person, but says this does not automatically exclude work produced with AI assistance. Where a person contributes genuine skill and labour—including through instructions given to an AI system—copyright protection may still be justified, he says, with the degree of human contribution assessed case by case.
He also outlines two potential directions for copyright reform: strengthening creators’ moral rights and improving public access to creative works. Moral rights, he writes, protect the personal connection between a creator and their work rather than its economic value. One proposal is to give creators a moral right to object when their work is used to train AI, which he says would recognise artists’ emotional connection to their work and could not be sold like an economic right.
The paper points to a recent Australian example in which a film director sued his production company for alleged breach of moral rights related to authorship acknowledgement.
On public access, Yuvaraj argues that because creativity is often communal—building on existing works, traditions and shared cultural contributions—copyright law should make works more accessible while preserving creators’ economic rights. Options discussed include open-access publishing, compulsory licensing schemes, and exceptions allowing certain uses without permission. He also raises whether communal rights could better reflect collective creativity in Indigenous and First Nations communities.

